All-too fallible: On India’s vote against moratorium on death penalty

Context
India recently voted against a proposed global moratorium on the death penalty at the United Nations, maintaining its stance that capital punishment is a sovereign decision backed by judicial safeguards. However, the editorial highlights the growing contradiction between India's international position and domestic realities, noting an increase in death row inmates and the expansion of capital offences under the new , despite concerns over the criminal justice system's fallibility.
Exam perspectives
The debate over capital punishment in India is deeply intertwined with the interpretation of Article 21 of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to life and personal liberty, except according to procedure established by law. The Supreme Court, in the landmark Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) case, upheld the constitutional validity of the death penalty but restricted its application to the 'rarest of rare' cases. This doctrine requires courts to weigh aggravating and mitigating circumstances before imposing the ultimate punishment. The editorial points out a critical flaw in the current system: the reliance on judicial safeguards, such as the requirement for a High Court's confirmation of a death sentence, is undermined by the systemic issues within the criminal justice system. The high number of death row inmates (574 as of late 2025) and the subsequent release of many by the Supreme Court after years of incarceration suggest that trial courts are frequently misapplying the 'rarest of rare' principle. This highlights the fallibility of the system and raises questions about whether the 'procedure established by law' is robust enough to prevent the execution of innocent individuals, especially those from marginalized backgrounds who often lack access to competent legal representation.
The expansion of capital offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (the new penal code replacing the IPC) is analyzed as an example of penal populism. This term refers to the political strategy of enacting harsher punishments, often in response to public outrage over heinous crimes (like sexual violence), to project a 'tough on crime' image. The editorial argues that this approach is fundamentally flawed from a governance perspective because it fails to address the root causes of crime and the systemic weaknesses in law enforcement. True deterrence is achieved not merely by the severity of the punishment but by the certainty of conviction. Poor policing, flawed investigations, and low conviction rates are the actual issues that undermine deterrence. The Law Commission of India, in its 2015 report headed by Justice A.P. Shah, concluded that the death penalty fails to achieve any constitutionally valid penological goals (like deterrence or retribution) and recommended its abolition for all crimes except terrorism and waging war. The governance challenge lies in shifting focus from symbolic harsh punishments to structural reforms aimed at improving investigative and prosecutorial practices and ensuring equitable access to legal aid.
The retention of the death penalty raises profound ethical questions regarding the state's moral authority to take a human life. The core ethical argument against capital punishment is the requirement of infallibility. Since the criminal justice system is operated by humans, it is inherently fallible. The risk of executing an innocent person—due to flawed evidence, false testimony, or inadequate legal defense—makes the death penalty an irrevocable and ethically precarious punishment. Furthermore, the editorial touches upon the concept of proportionality in punishment. Imposing excessively harsh punishments, such as the death penalty for non-fatal crimes, can lead to perverse incentives, potentially encouraging offenders to escalate violence to eliminate witnesses and evade capture. From an ethical standpoint, the focus of the justice system should ideally lean towards reformative justice rather than purely retributive measures. The state's commitment to human rights and dignity is often measured by how it treats its most vulnerable, including those condemned to death. The uneven application of the death penalty, where socio-economically disadvantaged individuals are disproportionately represented on death row, highlights a systemic ethical failure to provide equal justice under the law.
Key references
AI-generated study notes, sourced from The Hindu. Verify facts and figures with standard sources.