Pakistan’s participation in SCO Civilisational Forum | Explained

Context
Pakistan has nominated its Minister for Climate Change and Coordination, Musadik Masud Malik, to attend the inaugural in New Delhi. The event, part of the (SCO) structure, aims to connect ancient civilisations among member countries. The participation is notable given recent tensions, specifically India's decision to re-evaluate the following a terror attack, a move heavily criticized by the nominated minister.
Exam perspectives
The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) is a vital Eurasian political, economic, and security alliance, originally formed by the 'Shanghai Five' in 1996 and formally established in 2001. India and Pakistan joined as full members in 2017. For UPSC, it's crucial to understand that the SCO operates on the 'Shanghai Spirit', which emphasizes mutual trust, mutual benefit, equality, and respect for cultural diversity. The introduction of the SCO Civilisational Forum highlights a shift towards cultural diplomacy and soft power within the organization, aiming to foster ties based on shared historical linkages (like the Indus Valley Civilization spanning India and Pakistan). Despite the overarching theme of civilizational dialogue, the reality of bilateral friction often shadows multilateral engagements. Pakistan's decision to send a minister, especially one critical of India's recent actions, underscores the complex interplay where countries use multilateral forums to signal diplomatic posturing while managing fraught bilateral ties. The SCO charter prohibits raising bilateral issues, forcing members to navigate these tensions carefully.
The underlying tension in this diplomatic engagement revolves around the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), signed in 1960. The IWT is a crucial water-sharing arrangement brokered by the World Bank. It allocates the waters of three eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas, Sutlej) to India for unrestricted use, while the waters of the three western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab) are largely allocated to Pakistan, though India is permitted limited agricultural use and unrestricted non-consumptive uses, such as run-of-the-river hydroelectric projects. The geography of the Indus basin makes India the upper riparian state, giving it significant strategic leverage. The mentioned possibility of India putting the treaty 'in abeyance' touches upon the legal principles of international treaties under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (specifically Article 62 concerning a fundamental change of circumstances). India's recent notices to modify the treaty stem from dissatisfaction with Pakistan's perceived 'intransigence' over dispute resolution mechanisms concerning Indian projects like Kishenganga and Ratle. This highlights the concept of hydro-diplomacy and how control over transboundary water resources becomes a tool of strategic coercion and conflict resolution.
The intersection of terrorism and diplomatic/resource treaties is a key governance challenge. The article notes the potential suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty following the Pahalgam terror attack. This reflects a shift in India's policy framework, often summarized by the phrase 'blood and water cannot flow together'. This approach signals a move away from compartmentalizing issues (treating water sharing as separate from security concerns) towards issue linkage, where compliance with bilateral agreements is contingent on specific security behaviors (i.e., halting cross-border terrorism). From a governance perspective, this raises questions about the sanctity of international agreements versus national security imperatives. While treaties generally require adherence (Pacta sunt servanda), the use of strategic resources as diplomatic leverage requires careful calculation, as it can escalate tensions and attract international scrutiny, particularly from mediators like the World Bank.
Key references
AI-generated study notes, sourced from The Hindu. Verify facts and figures with standard sources.